By Mackenzie Pryor
Science at Wolcott is fun, engaging, and supportive. We prioritize a variety of strategies to keep students engaged in the sciences, including traditional and inquiry-based labs, demonstrations, simulations, manipulatives, and the use of college-level equipment. Through these exciting opportunities, students are empowered to explore science as a potential career. Wolcott is committed not only to cultivating scientific skills, but also to developing students’ communication abilities, enabling them to discuss the importance of the labs and activities they experience.
While science is exciting, its true value lies in the scientists’ abilities to clearly explain concepts and communicate its significance to others. At Wolcott, we use the Claim-Evidence-Reasoning (CER) framework to teach students the foundations of a scientific argument. CERs are scientific explanations broken down into three parts. The claim is a sentence that answers the guiding question, the evidence is specific data or observations from the investigation, and the reasoning explains how the evidence supports the claim and links it to relevant scientific principles.
Scaffolds:
Writing large amounts of texts can be daunting for anybody, but particularly for diverse learners. Because of this, the science department has been working for years to scaffold the CER writing process to ensure that students create detailed, well-organized responses while understanding the process and expectations. Scaffolds we have developed include clear formatting and assessment guidelines.
The science team at Wolcott has created a template that separates CERs into its three parts: claim, evidence, and reasoning. This allows students to focus on each section independently rather than writing one long essay. By doing so, students are less likely to leave out key components and can visually track their progress.
Additionally, the science team has developed thoughtful and detailed CER rubrics for each grade. These are visible in every classroom, Google Classroom, and CER assignment. This allows for students to be held to high expectations while minimizing student questions and confusion. Whether your student is taking Physics, Biology, Chemistry, or Robotics, the same CER template and rubrics are used. This consistency allows students to build upon their skills year after year while mitigating uncertainty surrounding expectations across classes and teachers. These scaffolds make a daunting task feel more approachable.
Supports:
CER writing is also a highly supportive process. They are typically completed in class with teacher guidance, but students can access additional help during Academic Coaching after school, Learning Strategies during school, or informally before school for one-on-one support. Despite this, there may be times when students are working on CERs independently, and Wolcott science teachers are committed to supporting student success regardless of access. To further assist students working independently, the Wolcott science team created a CER Support Document. This document includes three sections.
The first section is “Sentence Starters”. This section is formatted in the same template as the CER template to provide students with a visual of the type of information that is included in each section. Sentence starters reduce writer’s block, as a starting point might be what the student needs to get their ideas down on paper. In addition, they prompt deeper analysis by modeling how to elaborate and justify thinking using academic language.
The second section is “Mind Mapping”. This section is organized as a step-by-step process with examples to help students organize information visually. Mind mapping is beneficial for students who are having trouble identifying relevant information. By “brain dumping” and visually linking concepts, students are more easily able to see how ideas relate, which in turn helps them organize their CER.
The third section is “CER Examples”. This section includes an example CER at each grade-level to provide clear models of what a thorough CER looks like. Examples reduce confusion and anxiety, as students are more confident starting their own work when they have a clear model to follow, and seeing the quality of work expected provides students with the confidence to achieve this in their own work. Teachers regularly model the use of these supports in class to ensure students can apply them independently.
Vertical Alignment:
CERs are vertically aligned across grade-levels, increasing in complexity and expectation from 9th to 12th grade. This progression allows students to master CERs at each stage and build new skills each year. By their senior year, Wolcott science students can write clear and robust CERs (no longer needing much of the support discussed above), expand them into larger reports, and present their findings in ways similar to university poster sessions or academic conferences.
The growth in skill and confidence from freshman to senior year demonstrates the success of Wolcott’s scaffolds and supports in producing confident science communicators upon graduation. Coupled with expert faculty guidance, students learn how to use the tools offered until they are no longer needed. Observing students perform a task that once seemed daunting with confidence and clarity is a testament to the growth they experience throughout high school at Wolcott. Graduates leave Wolcott prepared not only with the technical skills required for careers in science, but also with the communication and problem-solving skills necessary to overcome novel scientific challenges.




